Bill Bosacker

This is just my normal user blog for things that don't fit in the other blogs, but are tailored for the open source C/C++/C# and .NET communities.
A look behind "The Mojave Experiment"

After reading Dave Burke's post Everyman Links for July 25, 2008, I immediately wondered what was actually presented to these people as the information presented was very limited.  The major points of interest were:

  • How was the hardware requirements issue addressed?
  • Was the newbie vs experienced user issue addressed?

The overall answer is that "The Mojave Experiment" is nothing but smoke and mirrors.  None of the issues are properly addressed.  The laptops used are about a year old, which is well after machines were built for Vista.  Machines that were not built for Vista will perform at about 1/4 of the performance that they enjoyed under Windows 2003 or Windows XP.  Also, 2GB of RAM (the amount that the demo laptops had) is the minimum amount of RAM that anyone should have, with 4GB being the minimum for developers.

When you see the ooooohhh's and aaahhhhh's at some of the features (i.e. search) think about whether or not it is something that would actually help you.  It may look slick and all, but after using it for a while most of these features will actually slow you down.  Do you like the right click search for files in Windows Explorer?  Gone.  It's been replaced by a completely different system that is not at all friendly to experienced users.

To see "The Mojave Experiment" and decide for your yourself, go to:

http://www.mojaveexperiment.com/

Let me know your thoughts as I think that Microsoft is really grasping at straws at this point.

Published Wednesday, September 03, 2008 8:04 PM by Bill Bosacker

Comments

# re: A look behind "The Mojave Experiment"@ Wednesday, September 03, 2008 10:01 PM

You've always been a troublemaker... :-)  Thanks for the link anyway!  I guess I was so struck by Mojave before it seemed so un-Microsoft.

Dave Burke

# re: A look behind "The Mojave Experiment"@ Wednesday, September 03, 2008 11:15 PM

Hey Dave, you know me well.  I had some great teachers and mentors in my past, and I did some entertainment work in the early 90s.  Because of that, I am always thinking, "What are they NOT saying?"  When it comes to advertising the most important words are those that are not said.

Tonight was the first night that I had seen a Mojave commercial.  It and all the videos on the web site are heavily edited to remove anything that does not reflect nicely on Vista.  The sad thing is that if they had hired a professional ad company to do this, it wouldn't be as obvious.

Bill Bosacker

Leave a Comment

(required) 
(required) 
(optional)
(required)